Differentiation of NASHA and OBT Hyaluronic Acid Gels According to Strength, Flexibility, and Associated Clinical Significance

January 2024 | Volume 23 | Issue 1 | 1332 | Copyright © January 2024


Published online December 12, 2023

Ake Ohrlund MSc, Per Winlof BSc, Torun Bromee PhD, Inna Prygova MD

Galderma, Uppsala, Sweden

Abstract
Background: With a wide range of hyaluronic acid (HA) filler products available, knowledge of gel characteristics is a key part of tailoring treatments to each patient's aesthetic goals. This paper presents 2 main gel characteristics - strength/firmness and flexibility - for HA fillers produced using NASHA® and OBT™ and their clinical significance for tissue performance.
Methods: Three NASHA gels (Restylane®; Restylane Silk; Restylane Lyft) and 4 OBT gels (Restylane Refyne; Restylane Kysse; Restylane Volyme; Restylane Defyne) were studied in dynamic mode using a PP25 rheometric measuring system at 25 degrees C. Gel strength/firmness was measured using frequency sweep, with G prime evaluated at 0.1 Hz. Flexibility assessments used amplitude sweep measurements between 0.1% and 10,000% strain at 1 Hz, with xStrain being the strain value at the crossover point where G prime and G double prime have the same value. 
Results: Restylane, Restylane Silk, and Restylane Lyft had G primes of 701, 416, and 799 Pa, respectively. OBT G primes for Restylane Refyne, Restylane Kysse, Restylane Volyme, and Restylane Defyne were 70, 160, 171, and 271 Pa, respectively. The xStrain values were 1,442% (Restylane Refyne), 908% (Restylane Kysse), 930% (Restylane Volyme), 761% (Restylane Defyne), 7% (Restylane), 19% (Restylane Silk), and 17% (Restylane Lyft). 
Conclusions: OBT products had high flexibility (tolerance to deformation) and low to intermediate strength/firmness, which make them appropriate for dynamic facial areas. NASHA products showed greater strength/firmness, with the potential to create lift and projection. Altogether, NASHA and OBT HA gels covered a wide range of strength and flexibility.

J Drugs Dermatol. 2024;23(1):1332-1336.     doi:10.36849/JDD.7648

INTRODUCTION

The demand for minimally invasive aesthetic treatments, including hyaluronic acid (HA) fillers, has grown significantly in recent years, with the uptake of such procedures rising by more than 75% in the United States (US) over the past decade.1,2 Clinician experience, expertise, and confidence in handling and administering these products have subsequently grown.1,3 HA fillers provide a durable, yet non-permanent, non-surgical option to address facial volumetric changes associated with aging.2,4-9 HA filler treatments in general aim to provide volume so that the face appears lifted while looking even and natural.2,4-6 

HA gel strength/firmness is usually expressed as the elastic modulus, or G prime (G'), while flexibility can be defined by the xStrain (the strain value for the G prime/G double prime [G"] crossover in the amplitude sweep).2,10,11 The xStrain represents the furthest point at which the gel can recover following deformation.2,11 Beyond this point, the gel begins to behave more like a liquid and will no longer be able to return to its original shape.2,11 Because G prime and xStrain are two separate properties and not necessarily linked, products with similar G primes may exhibit different xStrains and vice versa.12 Products with a higher G prime are stronger and more resistant to deformation than those with a lower G prime.12 Products with higher xStrain are more flexible than those with lower xStrain values.11,12 
 
The NASHA® technology, used for Restylane®, Restylane Silk (R. Silk), and Restylane Lyft (R. Lyft), allows for the preservation of the naturally long HA chains resulting in strong gels with high G primes. In addition, the NASHA technology uses minimal modification and controlled particle sizing.11,13-17 HA fillers produced with NASHA exist both with and without lidocaine.13,16,17 The OBT™ technology (referred to as XpresHAn in the US) produces flexible HA fillers where the strength/firmness (G prime) is varied by applying different degrees of crosslinking.11,12,14,15,18-25 Fillers formulated using OBT include Restylane Refyne (R. Refyne), Restylane Kysse (R. Kysse), Restylane Defyne (R. Defyne), and Restylane Volyme (R. Volyme; Restylane Contour in the US).19-22,25