Intense Pulsed Light Pulse Configuration Manipulation Can Resolve the Classic Conflict Between Safety and Efficacy
November 2015 | Volume 14 | Issue 11 | Original Article | 1255 | Copyright © November 2015
Inna Belenky PhD, Cruzy Tagger MD, and Andrea Bingham RE
Viora Ltd., Jersey City, NJ
The widely used intense pulse light (IPL) technology was first commercially launched to the medical market in 1994 and similar to lasers,
is based on the basic principle of selective photothermolysis. The main conflict during treatments with light-based technologies is between safety and efficacy of the treatment. The aim of this study was to evaluate new IPL technology, which integrates three different
pulse configurations, with specific attention on the safety and efficacy of the treatment. 101 volunteers (with Fitzpatrick skin types I-VI) were treated as follows: 9 patients underwent 8 bi-weekly acne clearance treatments, 51 patients underwent 6-12 hair removal treatments, 11 patients were treated for general skin rejuvenation, 15 patients were treated for pigmentation lesions, and 15 patients were treated for vascular lesions. No serious adverse events were recorded. All patients that were treated for hair removal achieved significant
hair clearance. The patients with facial rosacea responded the fastest to the treatment. Eight of nine patients that were treated for acne clearance achieved significant reduction in acne appearance. The results represented in this study support the approach that when taking into consideration both efficacy of the treatment and safety of the patients, the system should be “flexible” enough to allow exact treatment settings profile for each patient, according to their skin type and the symptom’s biophysical characteristics. J Drugs Dermatol
The widely used intense pulsed light (IPL) technology was first commercially launched to the market for medical
use in 19941 and since then, many different devices and technology modifications have been introduced. Like in laser
technology, IPL technology is based on the basic principle of selective photothermolysis, wherein the absorption of photons via endogenous or exogenous chromophores within the skin are transferred as light energy. This transfer generates heat and subsequently destructs the target tissue.2 The target chromophores
in aesthetic applications are melanin, hemoglobin, water and porphyrin, which show broad light absorption spectrums. Since IPL technology emits a spectrum of wavelengths, these chromophores can be activated with one single light exposure, with convertible cut-off filters. On one hand, this versatility implies
a reduced selectivity to the target chromophore, but the specific wavelength together with the precise pulse duration will increase the selectivity in the photothermolysis process. As selective photothermolysis aims to destruct the target tissue without harming the surrounding tissue, the specific cut-off filters
(based on the target chromophore absorption profile) and the specific pulse duration (based on thermal relaxation time - TRT), should both be adjusted accordingly. In other words, the patient’s skin type and skin condition will determine the choice of suitable cut-off filter,2 while the biophysical characteristics of the target chromophore will influence the pulse duration. Pulse duration influences the optimum level of thermal absorption, but in order to prevent unselective damage to the surrounding tissue, the general rule of thumb is the pulse duration should be
shorter or equal to the TRT of the target tissue.3 The combination
of particular wavelengths, pulse durations, pulse intervals, and energy fluence, facilitates the treatment of a wide spectrum of skin conditions, such as unwanted hair growth, acne vulgaris,
pigmented lesions, vascular lesions, and other symptoms of photoaged skin.
However, the main conflict during treatments with light-based technologies is between safety and efficacy of the treatment. While high energy fluence may lead to higher thermal effect (more heat generation) and thus to more effective outcomes, the chance to accidentally cause side effects and complications also increases, especially for dark skin and Asian origin patients.
Hence, several manufacturers developed IPL technology with unique manipulations and changes in the pulse structure (or pulse configuration) with the safety profile of the treatment being the main consideration, while keeping a level of high performance.4,5
The aim of this study was to evaluate new IPL technology, which integrates three different pulse configurations, with specific attention
on the safety and efficacy of the treatment.
MATERIAL AND METHODS
Case Study Group
A group of 101 volunteers (57 females and 44 males) aged 15-70 years (average age, 39.6 years) with Fitzpatrick skin types I-VI participated in the study.