A Study of Glabellar Contraction Patterns in African Descendants

January 2025 | Volume 24 | Issue 1 | 57 | Copyright © January 2025


Published online December 18, 2024

doi:10.36849/JDD.8503

Suelen Montagner MDa, Najara Gomes dos Santos MDb, Camila Trindade de Almeida MDc, Carla de Sanctis Pecora MDd, Izolda Heydenrych MDe, Katleen da Cruz Conceição MDf, José Raul Montes MDg, Cheryl Burgess MDh, Ada Regina Trindade de Almeida MDb,c

aClínica Due Derma, Campinas, Brazil
bHospital of the Public Servants of São Paulo, São Paulo, Brazil
cFor Trials Pesquisa Clínica, São Paulo, Brazil
dDermatologie – Clínica, Cirurgia, Cosmiatria e Laser, São Paulo, Brazil
eCape Town Cosmetic Dermatology Centre, Century City, Cape Town, South Africa
fSanta Casa de Misericórdia do Rio de Janeiro, Brazil
gDepartment of Ophthalmology, University of Puerto Rico, San Juan, Puerto Rico
hCenter for Dermatology and Dermatologic Surgery. Washington, DC

Abstract
Background: Botulinum toxin is a well-established treatment for dynamic glabellar lines. Glabellar contraction patterns were described previously in the general Brazilian population and also among Koreans, Chinese, and Indian individuals. So far, no study has addressed glabellar contraction "patterns" in Black subjects.
Objective: To identify the glabellar contraction patterns in the Black population for a better treatment approach with botulinum toxin treatment.
Method: Pairs of photographs - at rest and under contraction - from 103 Black patients were analyzed according to a previously described classification based on the predominance of eyebrow approximation, depression, or elevation movements. Results: The 5 glabellar contraction patterns described previously - "U," "V," "convergent arrows," "omega," and "inverted omega" - could be identified in these patients.
Conclusion: The classification of glabellar wrinkles enables a more accurate individualized treatment with botulinum toxin in Black subjects, in addition to other ethnic groups.

J Drugs Dermatol. 2025;24(1):57-63. doi:10.36849/JDD.8503

INTRODUCTION

The glabella is the first area to be noticed in facial expression, and its contraction is usually associated with negative feelings.1,2 It is also the most frequently area studied and the first to receive US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) approval for cosmetic botulinum toxin treatment.3,4

Contraction of the glabella changes the position and height of the eyebrows, that are fundamental in face recognition and facial expression.5,6 It involves the action of several muscles such as corrugators and orbicularis oculi (which approximate and depress the eyebrows), procerus and depressor supercili (depressors), and the frontalis muscle (the only lifter of the upper face).7

Understanding the importance and necessity of this research lies in recognizing that glabellar expression lines stem from repetitive muscle contractions, which evolve from dynamic lines into static wrinkles over time.8-10 These wrinkles manifest differently due to various factors such as gender - where men typically exhibit thicker, oilier skin, larger muscle mass, well-defined superciliary arches, a more pronounced glabella,11 wider facial movements, and more severe facial wrinkles, particularly excluding the perioral area.12-14 Additionally, factors such as aging contribute, with volume loss and changes in muscle tone or laxity influencing wrinkle formation. Ethnicity, sun exposure, and physical activity further contribute to the variations observed in the development of these wrinkles.15-17 Understanding these multifaceted influences is crucial for developing effective treatment and prevention strategies.

Although the anatomy is similar among individuals, how individuals engage their musculature varies.8 A study showed that Europeans have generally larger facial movements than Asians, especially in the eyebrow, nose, and mouth regions. An exception must be made to the eye region, where Asians have a larger excursion of the eyelids.19 It is important to