Merkel Cell Carcinoma: Banal-Appearing, Aggressive Actor
Abstract
Merkel cell carcinoma is a rare but often deadly cutaneous
malignancy. It carries a 40 percent five-year mortality rate,
in contrast to 15 percent for malignant melanoma, and the
incidence is increasing among older and immunosuppressed
patients. Dermatologists need to be aware of the particular
diagnostic and treatment challenges as the incidence increases.
New data is helping to identify patients most at risk, accurately
stage the tumor and to optimize treatment regimens. With the
recent discovery of a virus as part of the etiology of this tumor,
approaches to use the body's immune system to attack the
tumor have potential to significantly increase survival rates in
the future.
Merkel Cell carcinoma (MCC) is a rare but aggressive
cutaneous malignancy. Its aggressive behavior, combined
with its asymptomatic clinical presentation, means that tumors
are often allowed to grow and spread before detection. As the
tumor becomes better characterized and its etiology better
understood, research is rapidly advancing in both pathogenesis
and treatment. Since the discovery of a viral etiology for this
tumor in 2008, progress is advancing rapidly.
Increasing Incidence
There are now approximately 1600 MCCs diagnosed each year,
almost quadrupling in incidence in the past 10 years. Data about
these diagnoses are difficult to track for several reasons. Until
2009, MCC did not have its own ICD-9 code and was simply
classified as non-melanoma skin cancer along with basal and
squamous cell carcinomas as 173. Since 2009 the code for MCC
is 209.3x, depending on location. Secondly, the diagnosis of
MCC is made at times by dermatologists, but at other times
by primary care physicians who excise a nodule which was
thought to be a cyst or other benign tumor.
Risk factors appear to be sun exposure and immunosuppression.
Indeed, a study of diagnosis locations between the right and
left side of the body in the U.S.1 showed increased incidence
on the left side of the body, particularly on the head, neck and
arms, likely reflecting the lifelong unprotected sun exposure
most individuals receive with daily car driving.
At time of diagnosis, 66 percent of patients have localized
disease, 27 percent have regional lymph node involvement and
seven percent have metastatic disease. Overall survival at five
years was 40 percent, reflecting death from malignancy as well
as the association of MCC with chronic lymphocytic leukemia,
solid organ transplants and other forms of immunosuppression.
Challenges With Diagnosis
Because of its banal clinical appearance and asymptomatic
presentation, diagnosis can be delayed until a tumor has grown
in size. In 2008, over 200 cases were analyzed for similarities2
and at least three of the following common features were found
in almost 90 percent of cases. To summarize and promote
awareness among dermatologists they are summarized in an
acronym, AEIOU, that describes the common features:
Pathogenesis
Despite being part of the neuroendocrine system, Merkel
cells are derived from the epidermis, rather than from the
neural crest. Because they share origins with most cells of the
epidermis, in the early 1990s positive cytokeratin 20 staining
was identified in the characteristic perinuclear dot pattern. The
CK20 immunostain has been a great development for both
dermatopathologists and medical research, because before
that time electron microscopy was required to definitively
diagnose this tumor
Polyomavirus Association
The most significant development in the understanding of
MCC was the association of the cancer with a new virus.3 This