Multi-Center Clinical Study and Review of Fractional Ablative CO2 Laser Resurfacing for the Treatment of Rhytides, Photoaging, Scars and Striae
April 2011 | Volume 10 | Issue 4 | Original Article | 352 | Copyright © April 2011
Macrene Alexiades-Armenakas MD PhD FAAD,a Deborah Sarnoff MD, Robert Gotkin MD, Neil Sadick MD
aAssistant Clinical Professor, Yale University School of Medicine; Director and Founder of the Dermatology and Laser Surgery Center, New York, NY
Abstract
Laser skin resurfacing has shifted over the past two decades from standard ablative resurfacing to non-ablative resurfacing and most
recently, to fractional laser resurfacing. In this most recent category, fractional non-ablative lasers were first introduced followed by
fractional ablative lasers, which offer an improved balance between safety and efficacy. In the current article, a review of fractional
ablative resurfacing is presented alongside the results from a multi-center clinical study employing the fractional carbon dioxide (CO2)
laser (SmartXide DOT, DEKA) for the treatment of rhytides, photoaging, scars and striae distensae.
J Drugs Dermatol. 2011;10(4):352-362.
INTRODUCTION
While highly effective in reducing rhytides, photoaging
and acne scarring, standard ablative laser
resurfacing was associated with significant side
effects and complications.1 In an effort to improve patient safety,
non-ablative laser resurfacing emerged, which while safe,
proved much less effective.1 In a more balanced approach, fractional
laser resurfacing was developed over the past several
years in an effort to combine the efficacy of standard laser resurfacing
with the safety of non-ablative modalities.2 Although
the first fractional laser device was non-ablative, producing microscopic
columns of thermal injury in the epidermis and upper
dermis, it pioneered a novel concept in lasers which has been
quickly applied to fractional ablative laser resurfacing.
In fractional ablative laser resurfacing, ablative wavelengths
including carbon dioxide (CO2) (10,600 nm), erbium(Er): YAG
(2940 nm) and the relatively novel yttrium aluminum garnet
(YSGG) (2790 nm) lasers are delivered in a microscopic array
to ablate microscopic columns of epidermis and dermis, with
intervening zones of untreated tissue.1 The key adjustable laser
parameters of power, pitch, dwell time and spot density determine
the percent surface area, penetration depth and clinical
recovery time and efficacy. An additional unique feature of the
fractional CO2 device presented here (SmartXide DOT, Deka)
is the multi-faceted adjustability of the size and shape of the
treatment area. Fractional CO2 laser resurfacing is an important
advance to the laser field, striking a balance between safety and
efficacy in the treatment of rhytides, photoaging and scars.
Fractional CO
In light of the fact that fractional non-ablative resurfacing yielded
minimal to modest efficacy per treatment and required multiple
treatments, fractional ablative lasers offered promise of
higher efficacy in fewer treatments. Instead of creating microscopic
columns of thermal injury, fractional ablative resurfacing
generates microscopic columns of ablated tissue extending
from the epidermis into the dermis. This approach increased efficacy
closer to that of standard ablative resurfacing, but without
the side effects and complications of the latter. The clinical
results following a single treatment are more significant as
compared to fractional non-ablative laser resurfacing, but the
procedure is associated with comparatively more discomfort,
post-operative erythema and recovery time.