Application Characteristics and Patient Preference of Triple-Combination vs Layered Topicals for Acne: Split-Face Study

October 2024 | Volume 23 | Issue 10 | 8430 | Copyright © October 2024


Published online September 25, 2024

doi:10.36849/JDD.8430

Zoe D. Draelos MD

Dermatology Consulting Services, PLLC, High Point, NC

Abstract
Background: Although triple-combination therapies for acne are generally more efficacious than dual-combinations or topical monotherapy, this benefit may be offset by reduced adherence to a complicated treatment regimen. Clindamycin phosphate 1.2%/adapalene 0.15%/benzoyl peroxide 3.1% (CAB; Cabtreo®, Ortho Dermatologics) gel is the first triple-combination topical approved for the treatment of acne. By delivering multiple active ingredients as a fixed-dose combination, CAB gel may improve ease of use, which can benefit both treatment adherence and efficacy. The objective of this study was to compare the application characteristics of CAB gel with the layered application of its 3 individual active ingredients.
Methods: In this split-face study, adults with acne-prone skin (N=25), self-applied CAB gel (0.3 cc) to 1 side of the face and layered benzoyl peroxide cream, adapalene gel, and clindamycin gel (0.1 cc each) on the opposite side. CAB and clindamycin gels were compounded with pyranine, which fluoresces under blue light. Photos taken under blue light were used to assess the uniformity of product application, and participants rated the evenness, speed, and ease of the 2 application regimens, as well as overall preference.
Results: Investigator-assessed evenness of application favored CAB gel over layered application in 100% of participants. All participants rated the application of CAB gel as more uniform, easier, and faster. Most (96%) preferred CAB gel for use at home.
Conclusion: Fixed-dose CAB gel was applied more evenly than separate application of its 3 active ingredients. By addressing 3 of the main acne pathogenic pathways in a single, easy-to-apply formulation, CAB gel may improve the efficacy of and adherence to acne treatment.

J Drugs Dermatol. 2024;23(10): doi:10.36849/JDD.8430

INTRODUCTION

In the treatment of acne, therapies that address multiple pathophysiological pathways are recommended for most patients.1 Combination therapies are generally more efficacious; in a meta-analysis of 221 clinical trials of 37 different acne interventions, triple-combination therapies incorporating a topical or oral antibiotic, topical retinoid, and benzoyl peroxide were consistently more efficacious than 2-product combinations or topical monotherapy.2 However, the real-world effectiveness of combining multiple products is less certain, as the addition of products to a treatment regimen increases the cost and complexity of treatment, both of which have been associated with decreases in treatment adherence.3,4

The effectiveness of topical acne treatment is further impacted by a medication’s physical properties. Aesthetic characteristics such as ease and uniformity of application, spreadability, and skin feel can influence patient acceptance of and adherence to treatment5-9 as well as drug delivery, efficacy, and tolerability.8-10

A thin, uniform film of the drug is ideal as it allows for greater absorption and penetration of active ingredients without leaving greasy or sticky residues on the skin.11,12 In contrast, thick or uneven applications may contain drugs that are never able to contact, much less penetrate, the skin;8 and excess drug remaining on the skin can contribute to treatment-related irritation.13 Beyond these clinical implications, excessively thick applications can be economically wasteful by decreasing the number of applications available from a given amount of product.

Clindamycin phosphate 1.2%/adapalene 0.15%/benzoyl peroxide 3.1% (CAB; Cabtreo®, Ortho Dermatologics) gel is the first fixed-dose triple-combination topical treatment approved by the US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) for the treatment of acne, and is indicated for patients 12 years of age and older.14 The active ingredients in CAB address 3 of the 4 pathophysiological mechanisms in acne (Table 1),1,15-17 and are