In Vivo Antibacterial Effects of Tretinoin-Clindamycin and Clindamycin Aloneon Propionibacterium acnes With Varying Clindamycin Minimum InhibitoryConcentration Levels
December 2012 | Volume 11 | Issue 12 | Original Article | 1434 | Copyright © December 2012
James J. Leyden MD
Department of Dermatology, University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, PA
Objective: To quantify the antimicrobial effect of clindamycin phosphate 1.2% and tretinoin 0.025% gel and 1% clindamycin phosphate
gel in patients with Propionibacterium acnes of varying sensitivity to clindamycin.
Design: Study 1 was an initial range-finding study that was neither blinded nor randomized. Study 2 was an open-label, randomized, splitface,
single-center study. Both studies were conducted in Pennsylvania.
Patients: Study 1 (n=20) and study 2 (n=22) involved healthy patients aged 18 years or older with initial P acnes levels ≥104/cm2 and minimum
inhibitory concentrations (MICs) ≥8 µg/mL for clindamycin.
Interventions: Study 1, clindamycin gel applied twice daily for 6 weeks. Study 2; once-daily application with the combination gel to one
cheek and clindamycin gel to the other side for 6 weeks.
Main Outcome Measure: The comparative effectiveness of each product vs P acnes of varying sensitivity to clindamycin at 3 and 6
Results: For study 1, at 3 and 6 weeks, clindamycin-treated patients with MICs of ≤256 µg/mL showed greater reductions than those with
MICs ≥512 µg/mL (P=.0001). Study 2 showed a significant reduction in P acnes for both products, with no differences found. Clindamycin
alone was more effective in vivo in patients with MIC levels of ≤256 µg/mL than patients with higher MIC levels. The combination product
produced a greater reduction than clindamycin alone after 6 weeks in patients with high MICs >512 µg/mL (P=.0047).
Conclusion: These studies suggest that 1% clindamycin alone produces a varying in vivo antimicrobial effect, with a breakpoint at ≤256
µg/mL. Use of clindamycin phosphate 1.2% and tretinoin 0.025% gel resulted in a significantly greater in vivo antimicrobial effect than
clindamycin alone in patients carrying P acnes with MICs of ≥512 µg/mL (P=.0047).
J Drugs Dermatol. 2012;11(12):1434-1438.
Propionibacterium acnes is the most common anaerobic, grampositive
organism recovered from normal skin, particularly in
areas rich in sebaceous glands.1 It preferentially resides within
sebaceous follicles as a symbiotic microbe. In the abnormal environment
of corneocytes and sebum found in the microcomedones, P
acnes proliferates and generates a variety of proinflammatory molecules
responsible for the inflammation seen in acne vulgaris.2-6
Over the past 20 years, the prevalence of P acnes to various
antibiotics has increased globally.7-8 The observed increase
in resistance exhibits the following minimum inhibitory concentrations
(MICs) rank order of insensitivity: erythromycin
> clindamycin > tetracycline > doxycycline > minocycline.7 In
unpublished results in 75 strains of P acnes with high erythromycin
MIC levels (1,024 µg/mL or greater), we found a range
of clindamycin MIC sensitivity levels that varied as follows: 8
strains, >1,024 µg/mL; 35 strains, 512 to 1,024 µg/mL; and 32
strains, <512 µg/mL. These findings are similar to other findings
in patients around the world.7
Currently, follicular antibiotic concentrations cannot be measured
and are unknown. As a result, microbiological breakpoints cannot
be easily determined. Furthermore, MIC levels are determined in in vitro aqueous systems, which may not correlate with intrafollicular
concentrations, since the latter is a lipid-rich environment.
In vivo human studies in patients with varying MIC levels may
be more helpful in determining MIC breakpoint sensitivity levels.9
The objectives of these in vivo studies were 2-fold: (1) to quantify
the effectiveness of clindamycin in suppressing P acnes that exhibit varying sensitivities to clindamycin, and (2) to determine
whether the presence of 0.025% tretinoin alters the in
vivo antimicrobial effects of clindamycin.
Two studies in patients with high numbers of P acnes, high levels
of erythromycin resistance, and varying MICs for clindamycin
The initial range-finding study population consisted of 20 healthy
male and female patients aged 18 years or older whose facial
(cheek) samples exhibited high P acnes MIC levels of at least ≥4
log10 colony-forming units (CFUs)/cm2 (≥10,000 colonies per cm2)
and with MICs of ≥8 µg/mL for clindamycin. Each patient was
treated with 1% clindamycin gel twice a day for 6 weeks.